| Round 1 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Ichiro Suzuki |
| 2 |
Cleveland |
Adam Dunn |
| 3 |
River City |
Roy Oswalt |
| 4 |
Sterling |
Jimmy Rollins |
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Paul LoDuca |
| 6 |
River City |
Alfonso Soriano |
| 7 |
Jersey |
Jason Marquis |
| 8 |
Independence |
CC Sabathia |
| 9 |
Garden State |
Joel Pineiro |
| 10 |
Jersey |
Ben Sheets |
| 11 |
Louisville |
Danys Baez |
| 12 |
Grandview |
Dave Williams |
| 13 |
River City |
Brandon Duckworth |
| 14 |
Bridgetown |
Chris Reitsma |
| 15 |
Denver |
Erik Hiljus |
| 16 |
Denver |
Nate Cornejo |
| |
|
| Round 2 |
| 1 |
Cleveland |
Marcus Giles |
| 2 |
Jersey |
Craig A. Wilson |
| 3 |
River City |
Tim Redding |
| 4 |
Louisville |
Dave Coggin |
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Brad Wilkerson |
| 6 |
Louisville |
Shea Hillebrand |
| 7 |
German Hungarian |
Aaron Rowand |
| 8 |
Independence |
Luke Prokopec |
| 9 |
Garden State |
Jason Larue |
| 10 |
Jersey |
Chad Fox |
| 11 |
Sterling |
Josh Towers |
| 12 |
River City |
Chris George |
| 13 |
Grandview |
John Riedling |
| 14 |
Bridgetown |
Ryan Franklin |
| 15 |
Denver |
Junior Spivey |
| 16 |
Sterling |
Gary Glover |
| |
|
| Round 3 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Randy Choate |
| 2 |
Cleveland |
Ryan Dreese |
| 3 |
Florida |
Ruben Sierra |
| 4 |
Sterling |
Victor Santos |
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Scott Stewart |
| 6 |
Cleveland |
Casey Fossum |
| 7 |
Florida |
Jeff Liefer |
| 8 |
Independence |
Jay Gibbons |
| 9 |
Garden State |
Mark DeRosa |
| 10 |
Jersey |
Giovanni Carrera |
| 11 |
Cleveland |
Jack Wilson |
| 12 |
Louisville |
Nelson Figueroa |
| 13 |
Denver |
Joe Beimel |
| 14 |
Denver |
Tom Gordon |
| 15 |
Cleveland |
Ted Lily |
| 16 |
Florida |
David Delucci |
| |
|
| Round 4 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Rudy Seanez |
| 2 |
Denver |
Tsyoshi Shinjo |
| 3 |
River City |
Josh Paul |
| 4 |
Sterling |
Randall Simon |
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Matt Ginter |
| 6 |
Danville |
Jim Brower |
| 7 |
Florida |
Jeff Reboulet |
| 8 |
Independence |
Johnny Estrada |
| 9 |
Texas |
Willis Roberts |
| 10 |
Texas |
Brandon Inge |
| 11 |
Texas |
Lance Davis |
| 12 |
Texas |
Cory Bailey |
| 13 |
Denver |
Brady Clark |
| 14 |
Bridgetown |
Jarrod Riggan |
| 15 |
Jersey |
Fernando Lunar |
| 16 |
Denver |
Jose Acevedo |
| |
|
| Round 5 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Bret Prinz |
| 2 |
Independence |
Luis Vizcaino |
| 3 |
River City |
Jake Westbrook |
| 4 |
Denver |
Mike Kinkade |
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Wes Helms |
| 6 |
Florida |
Rod Barajas |
| 7 |
Florida |
Robert Ellis |
| 8 |
Texas |
Rob Mackowiak |
| 9 |
Garden State |
Brian Roberts |
| 10 |
Texas |
Mike Buddie |
| 11 |
Louisville |
Dee Brown |
| 12 |
German Hungarian |
Timo Perez |
| 13 |
Denver |
Mark Wohlers |
| 14 |
Bridgetown |
Hector Mercado |
| 15 |
Garden State |
Rick Bauer |
| 16 |
Cleveland |
Larry Bigbie |
| |
|
| Round 6 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Hiram Bocachica |
| 2 |
Denver |
Lou Collier |
| 3 |
River City |
Robin Jennings |
| 4 |
Sterling |
Joey Eischen |
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Scott Macrae |
| 6 |
Florida |
Orlando Merced |
| 7 |
Florida |
Eric Sabel |
| 8 |
Independence |
Damaso Marte |
| 9 |
Garden State |
Troy Brohawn |
| 10 |
Independence |
Tike Redman |
| 11 |
Louisville |
AJ Hinch |
| 12 |
Texas |
Hector Ortiz |
| 13 |
Bridgetown |
Brian Simmons |
| 14 |
Bridgetown |
Troy Mattes |
| 15 |
Intercourse |
Ryan Voglesong |
| 16 |
Cleveland |
Tim Drew |
| |
|
| Round 7 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Ryan Kohlmeier |
| 2 |
Denver |
Mark Leiter |
| 3 |
Denver |
Sun-Woo Kim |
| 4 |
Sterling |
Adam Pettyjohn |
| 5 |
Florida |
Alan Levrault |
| 6 |
Florida |
John Wasdin |
| 7 |
Florida |
Rusty Meacham |
| 8 |
Independence |
Paxton Crawford |
| 9 |
Garden State |
Randy Keisler |
| 10 |
Jersey |
|
| 11 |
Louisville |
Brian Reith |
| 12 |
German Hungarian |
Bill Pulsipher |
| 13 |
Denver |
Bernard Gilkey |
| 14 |
Danville |
Dave Magadan |
| 15 |
German Hungarian |
Donnie Sadler |
| 16 |
Cleveland |
Lenny Harris |
| |
|
| Round 8 |
| 1 |
Danville |
Dave Borkowski |
| 2 |
Denver |
Ryan Jackson |
| 3 |
River City |
Heath Murray |
| 4 |
Sterling |
|
| 5 |
Intercourse |
Bobby Munoz |
|